Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Mike Buckley
Posts: 4561
Joined: 10 Jul 08 14:18

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Mike Buckley » 31 Oct 14 1:53

IDimager wrote:Looking at the code of your v2 script (I didn't run it yet), I would say that that script gives a more reliable result than the first one. This because when people select versioned image with main images together (for the v1 script) then those labels will be counted double...main and every version. This v2 script on,y looks at main versions which is better.
I'm not sure, but I think I used the V1 script. Understanding the intent of the thread, I intentionally applied the script only to my Main versions, not all versions.

Andrey_Ra
Posts: 57
Joined: 14 Apr 08 17:58
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Andrey_Ra » 31 Oct 14 7:04

IDimager wrote:This v2 script on,y looks at main versions which is better.
I have checked this now and you was right (surprise! :)). It is funny because mainly it is the indirect result :). I'm just looked the way of how to omit my requirement of selecting images and found some code in repository. But if you found this better - I will stay it without changes.
IDimager wrote:Ps. I think I see a bug in the v2 script when the progress is cancelled. Either just break and not free there or free and exit instead of break.
Corrected. Thanks. (But cancellation of the process is not works, somehow).
Andrey

Andrey_Ra
Posts: 57
Joined: 14 Apr 08 17:58
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Andrey_Ra » 31 Oct 14 8:04

Mike Buckley wrote:The key indicates that the yellow line represents the "average." If you change the key, all will be well. Rather than use the term, "summarized," perhaps use the term, "total." However, I don't know anything about statistics so "summarized" technically might be more accurate.
Oh. My bad. (I missed this when copied diagrams). Now I've corrected this.
PS. Many thanks for compliments :o, I appreciate it.
Andrey

gcoupe
Posts: 603
Joined: 16 Mar 05 19:29
Location: Heelweg, The Netherlands

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by gcoupe » 31 Oct 14 9:37

Here are my numbers:

Info
----
Frequency of number of assigned Labels for selected 57709 images:
0 Labels: 3870 ( 7%)
1 Labels: 7880 (14%)
2 Labels: 16538 (29%)
3 Labels: 16332 (28%)
4 Labels: 8905 (15%)
5 Labels: 2847 ( 5%)
6 Labels: 873 ( 2%)
7 Labels: 300 ( 1%)
8 Labels: 99 ( 0%)
9 Labels: 38 ( 0%)
10 Labels: 23 ( 0%)
11 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
12 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
13 Labels: 3 ( 0%)
14 Labels: 1 ( 0%)
15 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
16+ Labels: 0 ( 0%)

The count of images with zero labels is skewed high mainly because of two factors:
- RAW images mostly don't get metadata added to them (the JPG version does)
- Photos taken on my smartphone are copied to a folder included in the folders tracked by the catalog. From there, photos are copied to my main folder hierarchy and metadata added to the JPG versions.
Geoff Coupe
--------------
Photo Supreme /Windows 10 Pro 64 bits + Windows Home Server 2011 = DAM

Maxometr
Posts: 30
Joined: 04 Apr 12 7:27

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Maxometr » 31 Oct 14 9:54

Вот мои результаты, только еще 446 необработанных фото. Всего фотографий 9621

Инфо
--------
Frequency of number of assigned Labels for selected 9558 images:
0 Labels: 446 ( 5%)
1 Labels: 170 ( 2%)
2 Labels: 1584 (17%)
3 Labels: 2723 (28%)
4 Labels: 2396 (25%)
5 Labels: 1437 (15%)
6 Labels: 513 ( 5%)
7 Labels: 186 ( 2%)
8 Labels: 59 ( 1%)
9 Labels: 27 ( 0%)
10 Labels: 15 ( 0%)
11 Labels: 2 ( 0%)
12 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
13 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
14 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
15 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
16+ Labels: 0 ( 0%)

Andrey_Ra
Posts: 57
Joined: 14 Apr 08 17:58
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Andrey_Ra » 31 Oct 14 10:11

gcoupe and Maxometr I wish to thank you for your contribution!
Here are your personal graphs:
Frequency_gcoupe.png
Gcoupe's Collection
Frequency_gcoupe.png (49.65 KiB) Viewed 4357 times
Frequency_Maxometr.png
Maxometr's Collection
Frequency_Maxometr.png (50.53 KiB) Viewed 4357 times
PS. And I remind to all, that zeroes are not included in statistics.
Andrey

Mike Buckley
Posts: 4561
Joined: 10 Jul 08 14:18

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Mike Buckley » 31 Oct 14 15:07

Considering that I've still got the lead on the largest percentage of images assigned 8 or more labels, I can't wait to learn what the winning prize is. :mrgreen:

Hert
Posts: 20306
Joined: 13 Sep 03 7:24

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Hert » 31 Oct 14 15:12

You'd get the honours to also catalog all of our images with at least 8 labels ;)
This is a User-to-User forum which means that users post questions here for other users.
Feature requests, change suggestions, or bugs can be logged in the ticketing system

vlad
Posts: 965
Joined: 01 Sep 08 15:20

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by vlad » 31 Oct 14 16:11

Mike Buckley wrote:Considering that I've still got the lead on the largest percentage of images assigned 8 or more labels, I can't wait to learn what the winning prize is. :mrgreen:
Hi Mike, congratulations for the 1st place (so far) - but beware of Hert's winning prize! :wink:

I'm just curious: do you have the "Also assign its parents" option enabled in your labels? That could explain your using more labels per image than other people. But, frankly, I don't consider 8 or even 12 labels that many. Still, my guess is that you're undertaking a much more thorough cataloging job than most photographers have the inclination or patience to do. (The fact that you're using a controlled vocabulary, IIRC, already says a lot! And the label sets you kindly shared with us suggest a predilection for extensive but well-thought cataloging as well.)

Mike Buckley
Posts: 4561
Joined: 10 Jul 08 14:18

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Mike Buckley » 31 Oct 14 17:30

Mike Buckley wrote:do you have the "Also assign its parents" option enabled in your labels?
No. I also don't embed synonyms in the image file.
But, frankly, I don't consider 8 or even 12 labels that many.
So long as I win an enjoyable prize, that's the only thing I care about. :mrgreen:
Still, my guess is that you're undertaking a much more thorough cataloging job than most photographers have the inclination or patience to do. (The fact that you're using a controlled vocabulary, IIRC, already says a lot! And the label sets you kindly shared with us suggest a predilection for extensive but well-thought cataloging as well.)
You're correct that I use the David Reicks controlled vocabulary. The reason I'm so compulsive about assigning catalog labels is that I enjoy making theme-based slide shows. As an example, If I want to show photos of circular red objects, I can easily make that happen, not that I've ever done that.

Andrey_Ra
Posts: 57
Joined: 14 Apr 08 17:58
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Andrey_Ra » 31 Oct 14 18:24

I'm still waiting for more reports. vlad, how about to participate in survey?
Andrey

HCS
Posts: 147
Joined: 19 Feb 14 22:08

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by HCS » 31 Oct 14 19:30

My details.

Info
----
Frequency of number of assigned Labels for selected 68436 images:
0 Labels: 3967 ( 6%)
1 Labels: 5929 ( 9%)
2 Labels: 6886 (10%)
3 Labels: 13117 (19%)
4 Labels: 13662 (20%)
5 Labels: 7350 (11%)
6 Labels: 5034 ( 7%)
7 Labels: 4156 ( 6%)
8 Labels: 2335 ( 3%)
9 Labels: 2754 ( 4%)
10 Labels: 820 ( 1%)
11 Labels: 840 ( 1%)
12 Labels: 366 ( 1%)
13 Labels: 338 ( 0%)
14 Labels: 231 ( 0%)
15 Labels: 122 ( 0%)
16+ Labels: 529 ( 1%)

Andrey_Ra
Posts: 57
Joined: 14 Apr 08 17:58
Location: Moscow, Russia

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by Andrey_Ra » 31 Oct 14 20:42

HCS, thank you!
Frequency_HCS.png
HCS' Collection
Frequency_HCS.png (72.04 KiB) Viewed 4319 times
Andrey

User avatar
lippe
Posts: 1697
Joined: 12 Aug 06 12:26
Location: Wondelgem (Belgium)

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by lippe » 31 Oct 14 23:45

Mike,
Mike Buckley wrote:
lippe wrote: I think the hight number of zero labels is due the RAW-JPG are not versioned and only the raw versions have labels.
For the data to be meaningful in that situation, my thinking is that you should exclude the JPG files. In other words, I believe the data should be image-specific rather than file-specific.
You are right, i should excluded the jpg's where a Raw version exist. I also have tif with psd and jpg derivates. Here i should exluded the jpg and psd's. But is have also some jpg's that do not have a derivate. It's a bit complicated because is do not version them in Photo Supreme.
Photo Supreme V3, LR6, FPV, PSE14 - vaio i5 @ 2.5GHz + 8GB , 850 EVO 500GB - WD 1TB - Windows 10 Pro 64 bits- DS216play - EOS 600D

tstoddard
Posts: 559
Joined: 07 Sep 12 12:51

Re: Survey: How many labels you usually assign to the photo?

Post by tstoddard » 01 Nov 14 2:09

Here are the results from running the v2 script on my catalog.

Info
----
Frequency of number of assigned Labels for selected 24294 images:
0 Labels: 130 ( 1%)
1 Labels: 1310 ( 5%)
2 Labels: 5588 (23%)
3 Labels: 12160 (50%)
4 Labels: 4411 (18%)
5 Labels: 506 ( 2%)
6 Labels: 102 ( 0%)
7 Labels: 36 ( 0%)
8 Labels: 24 ( 0%)
9 Labels: 8 ( 0%)
10 Labels: 11 ( 0%)
11 Labels: 2 ( 0%)
12 Labels: 2 ( 0%)
13 Labels: 3 ( 0%)
14 Labels: 1 ( 0%)
15 Labels: 0 ( 0%)
16+ Labels: 0 ( 0%)


[Yes] [No]
Tom Stoddard

Post Reply